Since my inaugural post about Arizona Senate Bill 1070, I've received countless emails and response asking me what I thought of this controversial and seemingly polarizing little piece of legislation. It seems like everywhere you go these days, whether at the water cooler at work, or standing in the never-ending line at Subway while an over-weight, 27-year old named Jake tries to see over his giant nose-ring to "create" his next masterpiece and not cut his finger off; everyone wants to state their emphatic and "original", yet misguided and transparently plagiarized opinion on the merits of this bill.
Inevitably, as you sit quietly, nodding your head and listening to these "enlightened" souls spill out their latest canned jargon gleaned from the shock-jock on the radio on the way into work that day, they get around to asking you your opinion.
When I shrug my shoulders and say "I agree with what you said"....it seems to come off as an affront, or rude indifference to their "ingenious commentary".
The truth is.......Where I stand on the bill is irrelevant. Really - It doesn't matter. The truth is....this BILL is irrelevant.
Yes folks - sorry to disappoint you all, and as anti-climactic as it sounds - the soft, cushy, 3-ply toilet paper hanging way too low in my bathroom right now is worth more than anything written in Arizona State Senate Bill 1070.
That's right - All of the boycotts, mayor-on-state, state-on-state, mayor-on-state, etc., rhetoric and over-hyped media extravaganza that we've all been following like an all-girls nude tennis match, is much ado about NOTHING.
While certainly giving motivated and exploitative politicians, activists and other attention-craving public figures a convenient way to exploit this emotionally invigorating bill to get their names in the headlines, this bill accomplishes little else.
Simply put - this bill, whether overturned by the courts as unconstitutional, or indoctrinated into permanent public policy and then copied in other states; DOES NOTHING. Let me explain.
First off, if a bill this "revolutionary" - as heralded by the right......or this "outrageous" - as coined by the left, is so unprecedented, then ask yourself why the bill is an almost carbon copy of an existing Federal Law? If this bill was going to change anything whatsoever, why wouldn't the Federal Law already in tact been sufficient to do the same? If your answer is "Well, because now the State can enforce the law, whether the Federal Government does or not"....well then....read on.
As we all know, any bill put into law is only as effective as the particular government's ability to enforce that law.
In the State of Arizona, the divide in support and opposition of this bill is as strongly contested as the rest of the country. So much so, that even the Mayor of Arizona's largest metropolitan area, Phoenix - which politically speaking, is as influential a City to Arizona as a combination of Los Angeles, Sand Diego and San Francisco would be to California - is outwardly and adamantly opposed to this new legislation.
This means, that even if the Left's propaganda machine-created scenario of local police ripping innocent Hispanic Grandparents out of their cars on the side of the freeway and taking them from their starving children to deport them to the southern border of Mexico were to ring true, the synergistic effort it would take to implement the deportation and vilification of poor Mr. Rogers, would be virtually impossible to see through.
Start with the Local Police. These are human beings. These are people with families and children of their own. They are also people who's jobs have performance criteria that demands they focus on tasks such as crime prevention, DUI enforcement, crime-solving, traffic ticket distribution, etc., etc. Does anyone really believe that we are going to see individual police officers on the streets blindly arresting other-wise harmless, law-abiding people just for being Hispanic and not having identification?
Let's just say, for argument's sake - that the answer is "YES, we will see that kind of reckless, mercenary behavior from our local law enforcement". The state will still need to prove, under the burden of proof established by law, that the perpetrator is in fact, in the country illegally, and then, get a judge to order deportation. This requires a District Attorney, willing to add a case of "Grandpa-needs-to-go-home-just-because-this-law-says-so" to his already crippled and inefficiently over-crowded court docket. Times this by the 1,000's and tell me you're going to find a D.A. in the entire country, let alone the State of Arizona, who is going to utilize already scarce taxpayer funds to prosecute a case as benign and meaningless as this. Furthermore, the political ramifications of a move like this, especially without the support of the Federal Government and/or I.C.E., is tantamount to a political bullet to the temple for a District Attorney. No D.A. in this county is going to want to touch these cases whatsoever, regardless of their personal convictions regarding the bill.
Now - let's say that all of the above is wrong. The local police have rounded up 250 illegal grandparents, good Samaritans, and religious missionaries and taken them from their families.......and a D.A. says, "let's go ahead and use our resources to incarcerate these individuals and then prosecute"..........
Now what? - Reportedly, this bill was pushed through the legislature to help mitigate and/or offset the perceived costs of illegal immigration and to help re-balance the State's woeful budget. Now - let's go ahead and add in the cost of arrest, incarceration and full deportation of all of these innocent clergymen and Nobel Peace Prize Winners.
The deportation process is NOT an inexpensive process and it is widely known that almost 85% of individuals from south of the border who are deported from the U.S., are back into the country illegally within one (1) month.
So - is this revolving door of the continual deportation and re-deportation of individual "illegal aliens" going to save the State of Arizona ANY money whatsoever? Is this deportation effort going to do anything but ADD to the cost to fight this Civil War? One need no further evidence that the scenario(s) above are accurate, than to understand that Government is not looking for ways to add to their budget. If you play the nuances of this Bill out and look at it objectively from an enforcement standpoint, you will easily derive at the same conclusion I have - This bill is useless.....This bill changes Nothing.
This may lead to the obvious question - "why was the bill passed?".
That is an easy one.
The Republican Agenda includes, among other causes, the promulgation of the upper class......or the un-checked exploitation of Capitalism and the never-ending pursuit of the American Dream - which for many of them in Washington, includes yachts for them, the Fountain of Youth for their mistresses and bought-and-paid-for Ivy League Educations for their children. What is a way to ensure this "American Dream" is accomplished.....? ......CHEAP LABOR FOR BUSINESS OWNERS.
This may offend some people reading this, but pay attention - If the Republican Party really wanted to SOLVE illegal immigration, rather than capitalize from it.....they would focus on the actual Solution. We all know in our heart of hearts how to solve the problem if we really wanted to. It's not a cancer or heart disease issue for God's Sakes, it a "people keep coming into our yard and stealing our money" issue. How hard is that to solve?
Both Republicans and Democrats alike understand that to actually STOP illegal immigration, it starts in the workplace and ends at the border.
The start - Business. Take away the job opportunities, thereby rescaling the wage assignments in this country - and you'll take away their reason to come. Crack down on businesses that hire illegal immigrants....come up with a REAL way to identify citizenship....and prosecute businesses found to be exploiting the downtrodden immigrants by hiring them at sub-par wages and providing no benefits.
To End - The Borders. Fix the Immigration procedure so that real people who want to come here and contribute to society, have a means and an avenue to gain citizenship the legal way.
It's easy....and yet, we pass a bill that essentially does nothing...why? Because they DON'T want to solve the problem, but they DON'T want you to think that they don't want to solve the problem.
So, from a strategic standpoint, passage of this bill was genius. The Republican Party was able to pass a bill that allows them to continue their slave-labor exploits, while fooling their constituency into believing that they are "Fighting for you"....and/or....."Getting TOUGH on illegal immigration".
So far, I've noticed both parties falling lock-step in line with the master-plan. The Left legitimizes the Right's SmokeScreen....
...and from what I've seen....the Republican faithful are following like blind sheep or mindless Lemmings.......there is a cliff coming up though, and if the Sheep don't open their eyes, they are going to find the bottom. That's when they realize that all they've accomplished was putting Amnesty and Driver's Licenses, and health care and equal rights, for the very illegal immigrants they are trying to eradicate, right into the forefront of their opposition's political agenda.
That's my opinion. Thanks for reading.....
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
What Do I think About AZ Senate Bill 1070.....? What do YOU think about AZ State Senate Bill 1070.....? The Answer to both - "It doesn't matter"
Labels:
aliens,
Arizona Senate Bill 1070,
Deportation,
Illegal,
Immigration
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I AGREE THIS IS THE BIGGEST GAME OF "SMOKE & MIRRORS" EVER PERPETRATED ON THE ELECTORATE. WHEN THE ELECTION IS OVER IT WILL FADE FROM MEMORY.........UNTIL THE NEXT ELECTION. I AGREE , IT DOESN'T MATTER
ReplyDeleterALPH dYER
You couldn't be more clear than this! Thank you.
ReplyDeleteyou mentioned I would be surprised by your opinion, and to that point I say an emphatic Au Contraire!
ReplyDeleteI wasn't surprised by your opinion. That's the opinion of most everyone I've spoken with. Sort of a "meh. we'll see what ACTUALLY happens...." and then a shrug. Apparently my friends are disillusioned about all things politico.
My opinion rests firmly in the camp of "I have no opinion. Please pass a cookie." I feel my opinion resides there because I can't get all worked up over having my tax and health insurance money go to pay for people who don't have to pay for either of the above due to not being here legally. I am self employed at the lowest tax bracket so none of my hard earned monies go pay for anything, in fact at tax time the government so nicely hands over some cash MY direction, and because I can't afford health care so I'm not paying for random peoples I don't know when it comes to THAT either. I am an island. *cue music*
you didn't really ask for my opinion. But I felt I'd give it. Actually, technically you DID ask in the title, but I feel that was probably rhetoric used to elicit emotional response. although later tonight when I'm laying in bed hoping for dreams of you, I will pretend you asked me especially for my opinion while we sipped wine and gazed at each other bathed in candle-light as a well-dressed waiter stood by in his tux waiting for our exquisitely refined tastes to select a dinner course. Please don't forget to tip the violin player. He gets cranky.
Wow...I was expecting a quick little omni-directional comment and instead was met by a very intense albeit no stone unturned diatribe of imense proportions. Bravo. In today's get our info quick soundbite's less than 20 seconds world, I was forced to get on that inner tube ride down the lazy river that runs through the water park as I read. My only conscience return to anything status quo was when my tube bumped into the shores on either side reminding me of the pull to the "right" or the "left" as it were. Rather refreshing to see that others are pondering and not merely pandering...Oh, and on the issue of the bill? well, what can I say that has not already been said? It was an absolutely engineered response to a failing party who's trying desperately to regain a foothold in, well, anything at this point. Suddenly, the blog reader pauses and exclaims, "He must be a democrat, liberal, socialist, fascist, marxist, something or other", and clicks off in discust...To which I say, to the contrary, I voted for Bush in both elections and republican in the last (Not John McCain, however, and mostly because of his choice as a running mate) and also consider myself a conservative Christian who values God's best which includes not only family values, but social justice, caring for our planet, and comprehensive immigration reform that is humane. The republican party I have suported in the past has migrated so far past being what it was in our founding father's day that it should have been renamed. In the name of protecting capitalism (which has morphed into "feed the greed") we have sold our manufacturing to other countries (who now control us) and exploited the very workers on our soil who now that we have rung them dry, are kicking them out as if they were the one's at fault. I agree with Matt, American businesses caused the influx frenzy in the first place. We dropped a C note on the sidewalk and are now jailing them for picking it up. We screamed for less government and less oversight and what did we get? An unregulated mortgage and banking industry that brought out the crooks in most of us and brought this country to it's knees. And how about the sweeping energy deregulation and the tentacles that were severed in that "less big government" pull? The gulf of Mexico is crying out for any and all to hear. What is left of this once powerfull and all American party? we are left with Glenn and Rush spewing nothing but hatred and anti-American "hope this country fails" under this administration talk while the tea partiers try to send some kind of a garbled message of reform with no one leading who has any clear cut direction for what needs to be done. You've got John who tells us that he know's where Bin Laden is and will get him if he is elected! Quid pro quo? How about doing the right thing for the country as a US Senator and whispering it in someone's ear so we can do exactly that? Oh yeah, I forgot, he's not a Maverick anymore, in fact he never was one...? Then we have Sarah who has challenges with putting two sentences together and quit midstream on her Gov commitment to pursue making the big $ on her fame...But I have to admit, we do have some pretty memorable quote's that we wold not have if not for her. The one that I cannot get out of my head though was her last interview (7 month's of preparation) where she was asked what her plan was for the war conflict. Her reply? "We win, they lose"! That, last time I checked was a statement, not a plan. Anyway, look's like my job is calling me to do my part, so I will leave the shortcomings in the Democratic party for next post. Until then, hasta' la vista. Press 1...blah...blah...blah.
ReplyDeletePopsicola's comment reminds me of a pretty well-known quote from 'Utopia' - or at least well-known now that drew barrymore spouted it out in 'Ever After'....
ReplyDeleteFor if you suffer your people to be ill-educated, and their manners to be corrupted from their infancy, and then punish them for those crimes to which their first education disposed them, what else is to be concluded from this, but that you first make thieves and then punish them.
Sir Thomas More, Utopia, Book 1